Retro Review: Mastodon ‘Blood Mountain’

September 12, 2026, marked the twentieth anniversary of Blood Mountain, the third album from Atlanta, Georgia’s prog, sludge, stoner and psych metal legends Mastodon. With all the acclaim, and yes, notoriety, they have earned over the last two decades, it can be easy to forget just how truly groundbreaking they were at the turn of the millennium.

Mastodon'Blood Mountain' Artwork
Mastodon ‘Blood Mountain’ Artwork

Mastodon came together in 2000 when drummer/vocalist Brann Dailor and rhythm guitarist Bill Kelliher, both fresh off a stint with Steve Austin’s noise rock flamethrower Today Is The Day, migrated south from Rochester, New York. As legend has it, they met bassist/vocalist Troy Sanders and lead guitarist/vocalist Brent Hinds at a High On Fire show. The four musicians found instant chemistry, releasing the Lifesblood EP after signing to Relapse Records in August 2001.

With the fuse lit, the band struck back quickly with their earth-shaking debut full-length, Remission. On the strength of single March Of The Fire Ants, they soon became one of the most talked-about acts in heavy music. This was solidified with their second album, 2004’s Leviathan – a stone-cold classic of progressive sludge based on Herman Melville’s Moby Dick, featuring the legendary Blood And Thunder.

By then, they sat at the very vanguard of 21st-century metal alongside acts like Lamb of God and Queens Of The Stone Age. This was not nü metal; it was something else entirely—a movement accurately captured by The Relapse Contamination Festival in 2003 (I still have my DVD!), which featured groundbreaking performances by High On Fire, Neurosis, Pig Destroyer, The Dillinger Escape Plan, and of course Mastodon.

The combination of Leviathan’s success, critical praise, jaw-dropping instrumental skills, and a relentless touring schedule led to a major label deal with Reprise/Warner. The stage was set to write and record what I would argue is their most significant and singular album.

For their major label debut, the quartet once again enlisted Seattle producer Matt Bayless, who had helmed both Remission and Leviathan. Any discussion of Blood Mountain, even before getting into any of the head-spinning instrumentation or concepts, should begin with the vocals. Earlier material saw Hinds and Sanders emitting guttural growls similar to peers in ISIS and Neurosis.

While hints of that remain, both vocalists actually sing over the course of the record. That added sense of melody brings immediate nuance and balance to the songwriting. Like earlier releases, there is also an elemental theme: Remission dealt with fire, Leviathan with water, and here, the element is earth – fitting, as these mind-blowing compositions feel deeply tethered to this realm.

Featuring one of the absolute best drummers on the planet in Dailor, Blood Mountain (a place that actually exists in their Georgia homeland) fittingly opens with an insane drum roll intro followed by pick slides that announce The Wolf Is Loose. This thrashy, crunchy ripper introduces clean vocals alongside a few remaining growls, giving the group an excellent dichotomy. An amazing breakdown features harmonic guitar interplay, timeless riffs, and stellar dueling vocals.

Next up, Crystal Skull is a trippy, thundering affair featuring rhythmic drumming gymnastics, plenty of proggy twists, Herculean riffage, and guest vocals from an ex-Neurosis frontman. Both guitarists shine throughout, but Hinds’ insane shredding deserves special mention, as does the epic breakdown, complete with raw, cosmic-pirate bellowing.

We get a bit of a breather with the psychedelic metal and ascending prog of Sleeping Giant. Vocally, it is a great example of harmonized vocals, with Sanders’ throaty bellow offering a fantastic counterbalance to Hinds’ hazy drawl. Spacey, tumbling instrumentation and octopus-armed drumming serve as the backbone for celestial shred.

Capillarian Crest is up next, and it’s one of my absolute favorite songs of the last twenty years, metal or otherwise. It is a complex, dizzying, psychedelic heavy metal journey of the highest order. The drumming is otherworldly as the fills and beats are so jaw-dropping you can get lost listening to them alone. That would do a disservice, however, to the immaculate interstellar shredding that the guitarists engage in. Harmonizing off one another, they build toward a devastating, hammer-down breakdown as we are hit with lyrics like: “You, you don’t have to go escaping from the long way / You can’t leave us here all alone / Carve, carve out your soul, lay it on the altar, and leave us here all alone.” They then set the controls for the heart of the sun, blasting off into a staggering, face-melting finale.

a complex, dizzying, psychedelic heavy metal journey of the highest order…

Circle Cysquatch finds them staying in an astral, prog-thrash realm packed with filthy riffage, while Bladecatcher is a psychedelic mind-fuck of majestic proportions. Both tracks set up the cornerstone of the record: the Grammy-nominated Colony Of Birchmen.

Undoubtedly one of Mastodon’s finest songs, it features a guest appearance from Queens Of The Stone Agemastermind Josh Homme. His distinctive tone complements the chorus, but Hinds steals the show with climbing vocals, crushing fuzzed-out riffage, and intoxicating solos. It is as heavy and weird as it is melodic, offering a glimpse of where the band would take their music going forward.

Hitting the home stretch, Hunters Of The Sky is a massive, charging track with elevated vocals and spacey passages. Hand Of Stone follows as a perfectly sequenced, chugging riff monster showcasing their sense of dynamism. These then lead into another personal favorite, the epic, soaring This Mortal Coil. With a rising psychedelic main riff and Sanders‘ ethereal vocals, it pulls you into its vortex. During the chorus, the E-strings ring out before engaging in psych-infused riffery, creating an effect that is both imposing and emphatic.

The penultimate Siberian Divide features guest vocals from The Mars Volta’s Cedric Bixler-Zavala and serves as another insane musical journey stuffed with time changes and jaw-dropping drumming and all the interstellar shred one could possibly want. Closer Pendulous Skin is a spacey, watery mind-bender featuring southern-fried, tripped-out lead work and a hidden audio message from Homme, bringing Blood Mountain to a monumental conclusion.

The album’s touring cycle reached a dramatic climax at the 2007 MTV Video Music Awards in Las Vegas. A drunken Hinds got into a fight with members of System Of A Down and was sucker-punched, hitting his head on the pavement and suffering severe brain hemorrhaging that left him in critical condition. While recovering from the resulting dizziness and vertigo, he wrote much of the band’s next breakthrough masterpiece, the cosmic prog-metal opus Crack The Skye.

Successive releases saw Mastodon continue to expand their sound – with Dailor adding vocals to his drumming duties during the Crack The Skye era – solidifying their spot as 21st-century heavy metal titans. But as commercial success grew, so did internal friction. While his bandmates slowed down and started families, Hinds remained consumed by the rock and roll lifestyle, growing increasingly distant. Tensions boiled over following the tour for 2021’s double album Hushed And Grim, leading to his departure.

In an inexplicably tragic turn of events, Hinds was killed in a motorcycle accident in August 2025, robbing any chance of reconciliation with the men he built that legacy alongside. He was unequivocally one of the most unique guitarists of his generation, blending his banjo-playing roots with unmatched creativity to become a singular entity. One of one.

In the end, Blood Mountain served as the bridge between their early sludge days and the progressive metal machine they became. It remains a singular moment where four musicians expanded their vision while keeping one foot planted in their underground roots. It is among my favorite records of all time, and I continue to be amazed by its scope, vision, and sheer musicality. Rest in power, Brent Hinds.

Label: Reprise Records
Band Links: Official | Facebook | Bandcamp | Spotify | Instagram

Scribed by: Martin Williams